MARIEL R.
  • Blog
    • Second Blog
  • Happy Horse
  • Published
    • Free Stories >
      • Some Things Never Change
      • The Real Thing
      • For You, Mother
      • Meat Head the Worst Dog in the World
      • Boys As Nice as John
      • Meat Head
  • About
  • Green Gecko Publishing

What does "Published" really mean?

3/8/2013

 
Picture
I got an email from the second place winner the M.R. Jordan Winter Writing contest,  Doug Donnan. He asked me to send half of the Cathy Bryant's winnings.

To say the least, I'm pretty irritated right now. To choose the winner I used a scoring system for plot, character, setting, pace, and story arch. I didn't take grammar into consideration. I gave two bonus points for properly formatted manuscripts. Cathy won by two points and deservedly so.

Doug justified his request for more money because..
- He's a starving artist in Florida
- He's been published 40/50 times but decided not to clean up his manuscript for my contest.

In other words, he knew all the information in my critique and decided not to bother with it. Frankly, I gave him the benefit of the doubt. It doesn't feel good very good to hear he thought my contest was a garbage can to toss his work in.

I'm not rich and I've sold far less work than Doug has published. My prizes were small because they came from my pocket. I'm offended on deeper level because there were lots of fledgling authors who entered my contest-- that's who it was for. My intention above all things was to give other writers a little boost on this very hard road to success.

But Doug did bring up an important point. One I've been kind of making but maybe haven't said explicitly.

Published or sales?
There is a huge difference between writers who publish work and writers who sell work. I run a very small publishing company. When I get queries from writers with 50 or so publications to their name, a couple of things cross my mind, but the biggest question I have is, "Why are they querying me?"

I'm going to come back to that in just a minute. But first lets talk about my publishing credits. I have a couple non-paid credits at the very bottom. I have some semi-pro sales and I have one pro sale. I haven't cracked a big nut like Clark's World, Lore, Science Fiction and Fantasy, or Cemetery Dance.

Not all writing credits are created equal. It's a fact of life. Are  my credits impressive to an agent? Not really. I've sold work but I'm not writing pro work yet. Their respective value also depends on the project. Since most of my sales have been horror, my credits may actually work against me when I query books of other genres. Short-story credits are so relative to the situation, I mention them only in passing. In the war of writing credits, who has bought your work means more than how many times you've published.

Contests
Unless you've been nominated for something like the Bram Stoker Award (you have to have sold your work to a pro magazine, then it has to be nominated a lot to get into the contest), all contests have one glaring flaw: someone has to win. The award doesn't reflect on your writing in relation to all other authors. It only reflects on your writing relation to the entrants of that particular contest. Stories that win contests can have grammar flaws and structural errors, and depending on contest rules, these things may not matter. But they do matter if you want to sell your work to a publication like Esquire.

Agents and editors don't care about how many credits a writer has. They care about quality of those credits. And that brings me back that little question I ask myself when I don my editor hat. "Why is this writer querying me?"

Markets
So far the answer has always been this: They've been published markets that don't pay or edit. The writer doesn't have to change a single word.

When I used to send editing queries to these kind of writers,  they always responded in one of two ways:
"I've never been edited before so therefore I don't understand why my story would need editing now."  Don't get stuck here. Don't do it. 

"I dashed this off in five minutes."

These are two sentences you never want to say to an editor. The first one means any edits will be earth-shatteringly traumatic to the author and the second means he or she didn't care enough to send their best work. Why should the editor care if you don't? (On a side note, the five minute-rs are often shocked by any edits too. How could anyone think a story dashed off and sent without revision wouldn't need some? But I'm preaching to the choir on this.)

Don't take up residence
No pay/token pay markets and contests are a place to start. Don't "donate" your work more than five times. Enter all the contests you can win (see "low-class" for the one caveat.)-- some of the prize money is pretty good-- but don't put them on your resume`. Just say "I've won some contests" and leave it at that. And when the little ego monster (that all us authors need to write through all the doors that get slammed in our faces) starts thinking it's something special tell yourself this:

"No-pay/token pay markets are always desperate for content. All you have to be is the best of a heap that's really bad and sometimes all you have to do is breathe and type. Just because none of these markets have edited your work, does not mean your work doesn't need edited. They were an accomplishment, now they're not. You're better than this. Remember that 40, 50, 100, or 1000 no-pay/token pay publications means nothing. A writer with one sale to the New Yorker will carry more professional merit every time."



* Low-class: Imagine if J.K. Rowling, Stephen King, or Ray Bradbury went around entering blog contests like mine and squabbling over $25.00? That would be low-class, wouldn't it? Consider the contest you're entering. Don't enter contests that you consider beneath you and/or not worth the time it takes to put your best foot forward.

Valerie link
3/7/2013 10:55:59 pm

Grrrr....I'll never forget entering one of your contests and the little boost you gave me. Feel like I met a lifelong friend. It's very gracious of you to even host these contests.

M.R. Jordan link
3/8/2013 12:11:22 am

Thanks Valerie. One the plus side, the rest of the post is something I've been wanting to write about but couldn't find the words for until now.


Comments are closed.
    Picture

    RSS Feed

    Mariel R. is an ESL teacher, horse trainer, writer, editor, sporadic blogger,  and lover of beer. She lives in South Korea with two house cats, three horses, a German Shepherd and three barn cats .

    Picture
    Bear (Gom in Korean) )
    Picture
    Yeongji
    Picture
    Oreo
    Picture
    Panther
    Picture
    Thor
    Picture
    Thunder
    Picture
    Super
    Picture
    Rex
    Picture
    Geumbi (Goldy in English) R.I.P February, 23, 2018
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

    Categories

    All
    Advice
    Amazon Breakthrough Novel Award
    Authonomy
    Author Interviews
    Awards
    Bear
    Cats
    Contests
    Contest Winners
    Getting Published
    Guest Posts
    ICANN
    Icon Not Find It
    I Learned Something New
    Kindle Scout
    Misc
    National Identity Crisis
    Observations
    People I Respect Very Much
    Pets
    Rejections
    Reviews
    Site Outage
    South Korea
    Web.com
    Weebly
    Weebly Woes
    WHOIS
    Words That Amuse Me
    Writing
    Writing Woes

    Archives

    March 2020
    February 2020
    December 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    October 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011


Photos used under Creative Commons from cotaroba, Juliana Coutinho, Dare*2*Dream, Brett Jordan, plasticrevolver, Elvert Barnes, Dan-Scape.co.uk, Camp of Champions, Rowdy Rider, timsamoff, TiffanyMichelle Photography, expertinfantry, stormwarning., VarsityLife, Instagram: Brunobrunan, woodleywonderworks, HotlantaVoyeur, Ally Mauro, eBomb716, kalleboo, 1la, DonkeyHotey, trekkyandy, Dita Margarita, ZeroOne, Marina Aguiar Araujo, You Have Reached The End of The Internet, InSapphoWeTrust, Nina J. G., One Way Stock, Ronnie Garcia, +Angst, Anika Malone, evolvingblue, porschelinn, Horia Varlan, Fred Jala, Dyl86, Cia de Foto, mootown, boolve, final gather, Hexidecimal, Arya Ziai, h.koppdelaney, Fan of Retail, (Domino), Celeste Vasconcelos, I .. C .. U, Nomadic Lass, Risager, taylorpad212, Benny(I am empty), Nomadic Lass, aloshbennett, Ben Mortimer Photography, Suedehead, Kyknoord, Lunar Logic, simononly, mike138, Tim Sheerman-Chase, Rusty Clark, papalars, rocketjim54, dno1967b, Tomasz Stasiuk, Robert S. Donovan, Merelymel13, Crystl, Tirso Lecointere, Leo Hidalgo (@yompyz), david_shankbone, gpatague online porfolio, petersejersen, wadem, mikecogh, ravijain_92, mynameisharsha, World Series Boxing, Jackie L Chan, greggman, saebaryo, All Kinds of New, Dwilliams851, cuatrok77, woodleywonderworks, Alex E. Proimos, Average Jane, gagilas, LifeSupercharger, Incase., Robin Hutton, THX0477, greenchartreuse, BrtinBoston, Trev Grant, CocteauBoy, dno1967b, Matt Erasmus, Tax Credits, Josh (broma), Phillip Pessar, MoToMo, barmala, Steve Snodgrass, Ross Elliott, cell105, Hunter-Desportes, *clairity*, fauxto_digit, Hugo90, tauben, rococohobo, Spencer Cross, alexliivet, HelloImNik, br1dotcom, Jorge Franganillo, علي - ali, olgaberrios, glennharper, kyeniz, cogito ergo imago, chris.corwin, BagoGames, brewbooks, ϟnapshot 19, Pop Culture Geek, rockmixer, jphilipg, qwrrty, noniq, e53, 'Playingwithbrushes', Marcus Q, lowjumpingfrog, ingermaaike2, Bob Jagendorf, allaboutgeorge, mgrybos, Images_of_Money, Tambako the Jaguar, Foxtongue, DBduo Photography, Beige Alert, DieselDemon, Five Furlongs, danicuki, CamEvans, arne h, electricnerve, -Tripp-, bigcityal, Tim Pierce, Vidbynäs Golf Club, Anomalous Productions, Dovecoté Avenue, Shannon Badiee, Modern Event Preparedness, Amydeanne, Arenamontanus, snowpea&bokchoi, H.Adam, Victor Bezrukov, wwootton1, Bulldog Pottery, M.Ryan Photography, thskyt, Muscle Dominator, Pinti 1, crimfants, Maarten_G / GreenPictures.nl, gematrium, Helga Weber, jon_a_ross, stevendepolo, Starar Band, UT Connewitz, brad_holt, Looking Glass, NatalieMaynor, flowerguy, Peter Huys, The Good Reverend Flash, PhoTones_TAKUMA, greyloch, faceleg, odonata98, Blyzz, sgd, Jeffrey Beall, anneh632, Roy Montgomery, Ivan Marianelli, Lel4nd, autumn_bliss, briggz5d, orsorama, zzkt, Chasqui (Luis Tamayo), gruntzooki, Walt Stoneburner, marc falardeau, karlnorling, john antoni, Kris Krug, aussiegall, CarbonNYC, pheαnix - off 6/29 - 7/8, wwward0, Philo Nordlund, myhsu, US Army Africa, mrsdkrebs, bratha, Veronique Debord, susivinh, Wesley Fryer, Rubyran, Cali4beach, plindberg, Flikkesteph, Paul and Jill, Pilot Theatre, JoeInSouthernCA
  • Blog
    • Second Blog
  • Happy Horse
  • Published
    • Free Stories >
      • Some Things Never Change
      • The Real Thing
      • For You, Mother
      • Meat Head the Worst Dog in the World
      • Boys As Nice as John
      • Meat Head
  • About
  • Green Gecko Publishing